[Sdpg] (Jill Cloutier)-The Last of the Non GMO Corn Speaks Out! A Conversation With Corn
Wesley Roe and Santa Barbara Permaculture Network
lakinroe at silcom.com
Sun Nov 4 08:33:41 PST 2012
The Last of the Non GMO Corn Speaks Out!
I’ve interviewed farmers, scientists, ecologists, and permaculture
designers, but until today I’d never interviewed a plant.
A Conversation With Corn
J (Jill Cloutier)- Thanks for taking the time to talk with me today.
Tell me a bit about your background. Where were you born?
Corn (C)- My name is as Zea mays. I’m a member of the Poaceae family,
the grass family. All cereal grains belong to my family, including
wheat, rice, and rye. I’m an Annual, a monocot, and believed to have
been born in Mexico thousands of years ago. Like anything that’s been
around for a long time, I’ve had my ups and downs. For millennia, I
roamed the earth. My seeds were saved and passed down from generation to
generation. I was venerate and revered and used as food, fiber and in
ceremony. But, now that Monsanto’s got a hold of me, I’ll never be the same.
J- That brings me to the issue that I wanted to talk with you about
today. Genetic modification and the large role that you’ve played in
this controversial topic.
C- I didn’t volunteer for the job. I never asked to be modified.
J- What does it mean when something is genetically modified?
C- It’s a laboratory process where the genes from the DNA of one species
are taken out and put into the genes of an unrelated animal or plant.
The genes can be from insects, animals, humans, bacteria, or viruses.
J- I’ve read that 85% of the corn grown in the US is genetically
modified. How do you feel about being one of the most widely genetically
C- At first, my reaction was one of complete and utter despair. But now,
J- Why? What happens when you are genetically modified?
C- This gets a little personal, but basically it can happen in a number
of ways, genes can be shot from a gene gun into a plate of cells. Or
bacteria are used to invade cells with foreign DNA. The changed cell is
cloned into a plant. Most commonly, a gene from the bacterium Bacillus
thuringiensis is injected in me, so I secrete an insecticide that kills
corn root worm pests.
J- I have no idea what that means, but it sounds terrible.
C- I’m a food crop that’s bio-engineered to produce my own internal
insecticide. Quite frankly, it’s abusive. I’d rather have a rootworm
eating me then be violated like this.
J- Are genetically modified crops prevalent?
C- Oh yes, worldwide, an estimated 395 million acres or 160 million
hectares are planted with biotech or GM crops. In the United States,
more than 165 million acres have been planted. Most non-organic corn,
soy, and sugar beets contain genetic organisms. In fact, more than 90%
of the soybeans, canola, and cottonseed grown in the US are genetically
J- So I could be eating genetically modified organisms or GMO’s without
C- Not only eating them, but wearing genetically modified cotton, and
using GM cosmetics, like soap and shampoo. In fact, about 75% of the
processed food in the US contains GM ingredients. That meat substitute
you love? Most likely, GM soy. Those hard cheeses you buy? 90% of the
rennet used to make them is GM.
J- I’ve never seen genetically modified organisms listed as an
ingredient on any of the food that I buy.
C- That’s because labeling isn’t required in the United States. Even
though over 40 countries worldwide, including the European Union, Japan,
New Zealand, and Australia, require mandatory labeling of GMO’s.
Getting harder to find….most of the corn in the United States has been
J- Aren’t GM products safe?
C- Monsanto claims they are, but studies are now proving that GM
products can have dire consequences not only in the environment at
large, but also on animal and human health.
Have you heard of Roundup Ready GM crops? These seeds are one of
Monsanto’s best-selling products and include Roundup Ready soy, canola,
alfalfa, cotton, and sugar beets. Roundup Ready GM plants are
genetically engineered to resist the weed killer Roundup. Manufactured
by Monsanto, Roundup is the world’s best-selling herbicide. Farmers who
purchase and grow these seeds can spray Roundup directly onto their
crops. Even though Roundup is a toxin designed to kill plants, the crops
won’t die since they’re “ready for roundup.” Their selling point was
that farmers could increase their yields since weed growth would be
reduced. For example, Monsanto says that Roundup Ready alfalfa will
produce a higher quality hay and forage because of fewer weeds.
The problem is that the increased use of Roundup is having unintended
consequences. Research is showing that glyphosate is not as benign as
once thought. In ads Monsanto claimed that Roundup was “biodegradable”
and “safer than table salt.” But, some researchers have found glyphosate
to be an endocrine disruptor that can cause reproductive problems in
humans. Other studies have demonstrated that Roundup causes DNA damage
and birth defects in laboratory animals. It’s also been shown to have a
detrimental effect on beneficial soil organisms, which play an important
role in plant and soil health. A USDA study found that repeated use of
glyphosate affects the root structure of plants and may cause fungal
root diseases. Runoff from GM fields where Roundup use is intensive
could have a negative affect on the health of our waterways. Other
problems include the cross-pollination of GM plants with non GM plants,
resulting in wild GM plants that can spread. Some weeds are also
developing a resistance to Roundup and its active ingredient glyphosate.
Farmers are losing acreage to these so-called “Super Weeds.” Pollinators
have also been adversely affected by GM crops
Speaking of Monsanto, their GMO sweet corn, a new product by the way and
found at your local Walmart, is engineered to produce the insecticide Bt
and to tolerate Roundup. Studies have shown, including one by the
International Journal of Biological Sciences, that ingestion of
Monsanto’s GMO corn led to organ damage in mammals. The corn has also
been linked to a pathogen that can cause crop failure and livestock
To top it all off, many of the seeds from GM crops are patented and have
to be purchased from companies like Monsanto. If you try to save seeds
for future planting you could end up getting sued by a multi-billion
dollar corporation. Since 1997, Monsanto’s filed 145 lawsuits against
J- I’m beginning to think that genetically modified food is a really bad
C- That’s right. I wouldn’t even eat me.
J- There is the argument that GM foods are not that much different from
gardeners creating hybrid plants.
C- I’ve never seen a gardener splice the DNA of a fish into a tomato.
Plant breeders crossed organisms whose genetic makeups were similar.
Today, genes can be transferred between species that aren’t related at
all. Hybridization may take time and trials, but it doesn’t require a
clean room, microscopes, a gene gun, and the DNA of an Arctic flounder.
J- You sound worried.
C- I’m just a plant. I shouldn’t have to be concerned about these
things. I should be outside, growing with the sun on my leaves, turning
sunlight into food. That’s really incredible if you think about it. I
have my place and it’s not being spliced and injected with poisons that
can’t be washed off. This Bt thing really bums me out. I’m tired of
being laced with pesticides. I should have insects crawling around me.
Some of them actually help me grow. I want my integrity and my health
back. I want my reputation restored. My former job was to feed and
sustain. Now, look at me, I’m a genetic wreck.
J- What can we do to help you?
C- Boycott companies that sell GM seeds and manufacture GM food. Demand
labeling of GM products. Support local farmers who care for their soil.
Try to avoid ingesting the top GM crops- corn, soy, canola, and sugar
beets. The problem is these GM crops are found in most processed food.
Look for grass-fed organically produced beef, poultry, and dairy. A lot
of the animals that people eat are fed a steady diet of GM corn and soy.
If you live in California vote for Proposition 37 that would require
clear labels that let consumers know if the food they are eating contain
GMO’s. If the proposition passes in California it could set a precedent
for other states to follow. Take a look at the companies that are
against labeling and avoid their products.
J- Anything else you want to add?
C- I think my days as an integral, health-giving plant are numbered.
This is a case of corporate-sponsored botanicide and it seemed like no
one cared until recently.
Even worse is the idea that I’ve been patented. That’s really the last
straw. Corporations making fat checks off my demise, fiddling with my
DNA and making food that makes people sick. Hands off “Monsatan”, this
is war. Leave me alone. Let me grow in peace and continue doing what
I’ve been doing for thousands of years.
J- What can I do for you right now?
C- When it’s warm enough, go outside. Plant a few rows of me in the
ground. Use organic, heirloom varieties of corn, if you can still find
me. In a few days, I’ll emerge. Then help me grow. Feed the soil,
that’ll feed me. Once I’ve matured, eat and enjoy me. But, please save
some of my seeds and pass them around. Ensure that I survive, it’s up to
J- Thanks so much for your time today and all of your long years of
service. My friends and I will do everything we can to help you.
C- You’re welcome. You might want to talk to my old friends soy and
sugar beet, those two are really screwed and could use your help.
More information about the San-Diego-Permaculture